Full toot:
Many have tagged us in discussions about a specific Google extension built into Chromium browsers and asked us what we’ve done about it.
This is a part of the Google Meets browser extension, which we bundle in order to allow Google Meets to work. This can be disabled in Settings > Privacy and Security > Google Extensions > Meets. Disabling it will break Meets. We expose this as a setting because we want you to be able to control it, and disable it if you want to.
Disabling it by default would be great, but doing so would break Meets for users who are not able to understand why it’s broken, or what they need to change in order to allow it to work. Unfortunately, when websites break, either because of browser detection, or missing features, users invariably assume the browser is at fault rather than the website, and we have to make choices about what needs to be done to make websites work. We do not take these kinds of decisions lightly.
We do find it very interesting that Google, who run the Chromium browser project, choose to give Meets additional information that is not given to other videoconferencing websites, and this could easily be seen to be uncompetitive behaviour. Hopefully, the EU’s competition enforcement agencies can add this to their radar, and require a change in Google’s Meets functionality.
So Meet/Hangout does not work on Firefox at all? (In case the zero users who use Meet/Hangout see this)
Not sure about hangout, meet works fine just without some features. The main ones are sharing a specific tab and blurred/custom backgrounds but there might be some other minor stuff that I’ve never tried.
It works, though IIRC there are some features that only work in Chrome. I only use it once in a blue moon so I forget the details.
I suppose there might be features I’m missing from meets/Hangouts but 1) I don’t know what they might be, and 2) I’ve used the services regularly and not had any trouble.
I feel like most of Vivaldi’s target audience is knowledgeable enough to enable an extension that’s disabled by default. Heck, just display a notification asking whether to enable the extension when a Google Meet site is opened.
These proprietary, bundled-by-default extensions are just a taste of what a browser engine monopoly looks like. Alternative frontends to the Chromium engine don’t make a difference as these frontends will suck up whatever changes upstream. We only have 3 major/relevant engines left, Blink (Chromium), Gecko (Firefox) and WebKit (Safari, originated in Konqueror I think), with Blink being a fork of WebKit (although very diverged by now).
The web is so complex now that I don’t really see more engines becoming actually usable. Even Microsoft bailed out and eventually switched Edge over to Chromium.
Vivaldi’s target audience is people who don’t mind proprietary blobs as long as they are “good” or make things “work better.” Given that Vivaldi itself is essentially a proprietary blob combined with a Chromium backend this makes sense.
I feel like most of Vivaldi’s target audience is knowledgeable enough to enable an extension that’s disabled by default.
You could make the same argument in reverse. It’s irrelevant if we’re talking about knowledgeable people. The target market for significant growth is less knowledgeable people, so it makes more sense to cater defaults to that type of user.
A suggestion: disable it by default, and show a prompt and warning to Meet users asking if they want to enable this Meet extension, while warning them this would allow more tracking from Google.
Why not meet in the middle and make it a toast.
"Do you want Google Meets to be disabled?
Y/N
Sounds great! We’ve disabled settings for Google Meet, if you would like to re-enable it at any point, you can find it at…"
There. I even wrote most of it out for them.
Users will disable it and then a week later when they need it they’ve all forgotten about that dialog.
Seems like a simple check script for if at Google Meet then a red exclamation will appear saying you have it disabled and where to re-enable it.
