Something similar happened to Elliott Page for his work on the video game Beyond: Two Souls. An explicit part of his contract was that his mo-cap body model wouldn’t be rendered nude, but Quantic Dream did it anyway and then the nude model of his body leaked to the public.
If I recall correctly it was a rogue developer that decided to make a fully nude model and put Elliot’s head on it. So it isn’t a model of his body at the time, but still obviously a pretty big breach of trust.
Also this article was written in 2015 well before Elliot’s transition so that why it uses the older pronouns. I’m definitely a big believer in using a person’s proferred pronouns but I don’t it is “unfortunate” that older things have their old pronouns in them.
We’re at the point where anyone who’s been photographed from a variety of angles (video definitely counts) can have a reasonably accurate 3D model of their face generated. Bodies are much less important to get the details exactly right on, so that model can be slapped onto an approximately correct one and nobody’s going to notice the difference. Peter Cushing never had a detailed 3D scan done, for example, and they did a pretty good job resurrecting him for Rogue One. We can do even better now.
I have no good ideas for what the laws around this stuff “should” be. Just pointing out that from a technical perspective the question of “consent” is quickly becoming almost irrelevant - you don’t even have to tell someone you’ve made a model of them, and they have no way of knowing you did unless they see the results later on. Interesting times.
Something similar happened to Elliott Page for his work on the video game Beyond: Two Souls. An explicit part of his contract was that his mo-cap body model wouldn’t be rendered nude, but Quantic Dream did it anyway and then the nude model of his body leaked to the public.
A bit more info here (unfortunately this article is older and uses his former name): https://www.businessinsider.com/ellen-page-explored-legal-action-against-sony-over-nude-video-game-images-2015-4
If I recall correctly it was a rogue developer that decided to make a fully nude model and put Elliot’s head on it. So it isn’t a model of his body at the time, but still obviously a pretty big breach of trust.
Also this article was written in 2015 well before Elliot’s transition so that why it uses the older pronouns. I’m definitely a big believer in using a person’s proferred pronouns but I don’t it is “unfortunate” that older things have their old pronouns in them.
We’re at the point where anyone who’s been photographed from a variety of angles (video definitely counts) can have a reasonably accurate 3D model of their face generated. Bodies are much less important to get the details exactly right on, so that model can be slapped onto an approximately correct one and nobody’s going to notice the difference. Peter Cushing never had a detailed 3D scan done, for example, and they did a pretty good job resurrecting him for Rogue One. We can do even better now.
I have no good ideas for what the laws around this stuff “should” be. Just pointing out that from a technical perspective the question of “consent” is quickly becoming almost irrelevant - you don’t even have to tell someone you’ve made a model of them, and they have no way of knowing you did unless they see the results later on. Interesting times.