• 0 Posts
  • 7 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 8th, 2023

help-circle

  • Supply and demand is a science, and it’s that predictability that enables entities with large capital access to artificially limit supply to enforce market conditions preferential to them. (De beers).

    The free market is an idealised model which requires physically impossible assumptions to function. Regulation and approximations are what are required to ensure that the free market will tend towards balanced supply and demand instead of over-sized entities (monopolies and oligopolies) to exercise outsized market control. A slightly imperfect free market is still great, a grossly imperfect one is barely different from feudalism.

    In other words, we have anti-monopoly regulations for a reason. The problem arises when those with the power to control the entities with outsized influence are instead bought by them.

    (I am absolutely not pro free market btw, but it is a valid model for human behaviour when its assumptions are close enough to be approximated)


  • It’s always difficult for people to untangle their own experiences from being universal. It’s a common logical bias for most things, and we are all guilty of it at least occasionally.

    “I know better than you because I am __”. It is the classic anecdotes are not evidence.

    I personally am economically extremely communist while being very anti-soviet and anti-CCP, because I disagree with their authoritarian methods of enforcing socialism. Having grown up in a former Warsaw pact country I can see a lot of the great things that were outcomes of the communist ideals while simultaneously being surrounded by evidence of the awfulness as well. (And yes, I know “free” countries are also full of authoritarian bullshit and I am against that as well).

    I think it’s important to remember that the viewpoints of those who endured or witnessed the outcomes of, for example, soviet, control are recognised and heard. That way we are able to untangle the implicit knots between the bad parts of certain regimes and the actual economic and social principles of different systems. E.g. is capitalism bad because America is an imperialist shitty asshole country which is capitalist? No, it’s bad because its underlying principles are flawed, and they also incentivise America to be a shitty asshole country.

    It’s somewhat the same issue as the ad hominem fallacy, but towards a nation as an entity instead of a person.




  • Everything has a cost. Usually of the same type as what you are buying.

    You can usually reword security/stability as a type of freedom. The freedom to have a guaranteed income usually costs some of the freedom to choose where/when/how you work. For example.

    You might say that you will pay for the freedom to not have school shootings with the freedom to have free access to guns. You lose one freedom to gain another.

    You are correct that to some degree they are antonyms, but I would say that it’s freedom vs stability. It’s just that security is a type of stability.

    If you break them down more mathematically freedom is represented as infinite possible trajectories, which is in other words a very unstable position. In order to increase stability you must reduce the possible trajectories.