• 0 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle








  • You are ruling out intelligence without (very probably) being able to define it, just because you have a vague knowledge of how it works.

    The problem in this mode of thinking is a) that you put human brains in a different pedestal, even though they follow physical processes to “predict the next word” and may be very well neural networks themselves, and b) you are ignoring data that shows intelligence in multiple areas of the more complex models because “oh it’s mindless because I know it’s predicting tokens”. c) you favor of data that shows edge cases or probably that come from lower quality models.

    You’re not alone in this line of thinking.

    Your mind is set. You’ll not recognize intelligence when you see it.



  • I think you’re going by the English meaning of “conservative”. The word is badly chosen, because I don’t think they really are traditionalists. Probably “capitalist” would be a better fit. And paradoxically there are many things I find the “progressives” want to do which are in fact regressive. It’s a bit confusing and I think names should be changed to something else if it were up to me. Words have power, and words like “progressive” and “woke” have positive connotations while “conservative” has negative connotation which is sad; they don’t even apply anymore to the groups or ideas they represent.


  • I beg to differ. I think it’s very harmful.

    • There as absolutely no reason for anyone in Arch to use snap to install something mainstream like Firefox. Same goes for other OS’s like Fedora etc. (which are all mined in similar way, just change it to /fedora for instance).
    • The page presents itself as if it’s the only choice, and can easily scam someone who’s just getting into Linux into installing snap. I think it’s designed for that purpose. Arch links to the package, but not step by step guide (which is on Arch), but this can easily lure people into installing snap and being none the wiser the it’s not the default package manager for their distro.
    • It’s 4th for Firefox, but I’ve seen it as the top result for some other packages. Probably Google caught up, or probably for packages not mainstream as Firefox it still shows snap as number one result.

  • Your description is too reductive. You and I are also auto completes in some sense. See in order to complete a sentence well, you have to have a good model of a vast number of things including physics, psychology, linguistics, logical reasoning, socio economics, irony, sarcasm, arithmetic and many other things.

    It is currently unknown how much of these the complexity of the models and training process will allow, but they have been surprising us in every step. You wouldn’t expect a “just auto complete” to figure out rules of arithmetic, but it did. You wouldn’t expect it to answer tricky questions involving theory of mind, but it does. You wouldn’t expect it to solve graduate level questions but it is able to.

    So it’s a bit too rash to expect it to not understand rm -rf as humor, if you don’t know which model you will talk to.

    The smaller ones, sure, are dumb. But even GPT 3 will not recommend you to rm -rf; definitely not GPT 4.




  • bankimu@lemm.eetoLinux@lemmy.mlJump from Arch to NixOS?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    Your reason of “wish to start fresh” doesn’t sound compelling.

    Arch is stable, and works great. Biggest draw for NixOS is packages. I don’t think NixOS has anything to offer in packages that I can’t get in Arch. I’ll not advocate switching to an experimental distro with who knows what other headache, just because I can run Debian or rpm packages. Not for a daily driver.

    Do it only if you are bored or something.