• 1 Post
  • 28 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 7th, 2023

help-circle


  • Seems to me that anything beyond the actual hosting and serving of the video file is unnecessary to include by default in a federated video streaming solution…

    You are basically saying "Other than the most expensive and complicated parts" the rest is easy or unnecessary. Which isn't necessarily accurate but still is being a bit dismissive of the problems at hand.

    And one of the biggest criticisms of Peertube (aside from the dearth of content, which helpfully avoids the "expensive/complicated" parts) has been Discoverability. How do people watch your videos (or your playlist) if they don't have a way of knowing that your videos even exist?





  • WEI prevents ecosystem lock-in through hold-backs
    We had proposed a hold-back to prevent lock-in at the platform level. Essentially, some percentage of the time, say 5% or 10%, the WEI attestation would intentionally be omitted, and would look the same as if the user opted-out of WEI or the device is not supported.

    This is designed to prevent WEI from becoming “DRM for the web”.

    At least this acknowledges that this proposal would in fact be “DRM for the web” if the only thing from preventing it from being that is an additional measure unrelated to the core implementation.

    Not to mention, what prevents a future release of the feature either turning the percentage to 0% or removing the hold-back entirely?










  • …I trust the privacy guarantees even more since I’m a paying customer.

    How effective is this stance? While using a service for free basically guarantees there are privacy concerns, paying doesn’t directly provide any assurances. They can both charge you money and sell your data.

    But Kagi seems pretty expensive, and too reliant on Bing/Google search pricing to be a long-term solution.